Matt Carpenter sat alone in the locker room, after a dismal high school season. He was cut from the starting lineup by a shoulder injury, his grades were down, and his athletic scholarship was in danger of being revoked.
Carpenter, a shy kid, was beginning to believe that the MLB dream was a pipe dream.
And then, one quiet afternoon, Coach James Keller, his high school coach, walked up to him, put a piece of paper on the table, and said:
“You don’t have to be the best. But if you don’t quit, I won’t leave you.”
What was that piece of paper?
A handwritten practice schedule. No pressure. No discipline. Just an offer to play.
From that day on, whether it was Monday or Christmas, Coach Keller would come to the field with Carpenter at 5 a.m. They would throw, hit, run—in silence.
When Carpenter was accepted to TCU as a free agent, Coach Keller said nothing—he just stood there and waved.
St. Louis, 2011.
Matt Carpenter made his Cardinals debut. And just a few seasons later, he was an All-Star, hailed as one of the best hitters in MLB.
He called his old coach, but Coach Keller didn’t answer.
In 2015, Matt returned to El Paso to visit him.
Coach Keller was battling terminal lung cancer. His breathing was labored, but his eyes lit up when he saw his student walk in.
Carpenter brought a gift: the bat he’d played in the Dodgers win the year before, with a small inscription that read, “For Coach K – You never left.”
They didn’t say much. They just hugged each other for a long time.
/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/69145863/usa_today_15891787.0.jpg)
Three weeks later, Coach Keller died.
Matt Carpenter missed the funeral—he was pitching for the Cardinals in the deciding series. But he hit a home run that day. When he got to the dugout, he pulled a small piece of paper from his pocket—a copy of the 2004 practice schedule—and kissed it.
After the game, Carpenter had only one thing to say:
“I play for a lot of people. But that swing, it was for one person—the person who never gave up on me, even when I almost gave up.”